Elongated vs round toilet

The most difficult thing homeowners have to do when choosing a flushing toilet is to choose between an elongated and round one. You need to be familiar with the details of each type before you can choose. Comfort (Comfort Height or standard), size, water savings (1.28 or 1.28 GPF), ease-of-cleaning, ease of installation, single or dual flush, and maintenance are all important factors. This information will assist you in deciding which toilet is best for your bathroom.

Each has its own advantages and disadvantages. So what are the pros and cons of elongated vs round toilets?

Elongated vs round toilet

Are elongated toilets better than round toilets? Or are round toilets better than elongated toilets? Which are the best toilets to buy? Let us look at the pros and cons of elongated and round toilets and settle the score

WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ELONGATED AND ROUND TOILETS?


The major difference between an elongated and round toilet is the length and shape of the bowl. Elongated toilet bowls are oval-shaped and have a length of about 18.5 inches while round toilet bowls are circular with a length of about 16.5 inches.

Elongated toilets are more comfortable than round toilets while round toilets are more space-efficient than elongated toilets.

Elongated vs round toilet: which one looks better? The only difference between these two models is in the shape of the bowl and toilet seat. While the round version resembles a circle and extends less into the bathroom, the elongated model protrudes.

Features Comparison Chart: Elongated VS Round Toilet

Elongated vs round toilet
FeaturesElongated ToiletRound Toilet
Bowl Length(Generally)18.5 inches 16.5 inches
Good ForStandard/Big bathroomSmall Bathroom
Space SavingNoYes
More ComfortableComfortable for adults or handicapped Thin women/men or Children
FlushSome may have more forceful flushHas less forceful flush
PricingMore expensiveLess expensive
DesignModern designTraditional Design
Water SurfaceLargerSmall
PopularityIncreasingFading
CleaningMarginally EasierEasy

Enlongated bowl toilet

Elongated bowl toilets tend to be larger than round toilets when it comes down to size. An average elongated toilet is approximately 18.5 inches in length from the edge to the post holes.

The actual size of the bowl will vary from one model to the next. However, the bowl will always be larger than the round-bow toilet designs.

Pros
  • It’s very comfortable
  • Some models might have a strong flush
  • It’s a bit simpler to use and cleaner.
  • It’s more modern in design
Cons
  • ItIt won’t fit in small bathrooms
  • This toilet is more expensive than round-bow toilets.

In our opinion these two models TOTO CST244EF#01 and Swiss Madison Well Made Forever SM-1T254  are better in relation to quality-price, it also has a very good rating.

Swiss Madison Well Made Forever SM-1T254 St. Tropez One Piece Toilet, 26.6 x 15 x 31 inches, Glossy White
  • Modern design, clean, sleek look and compliment with different styles
  • Fully skirted trapway - extremely easy to clean
  • Sleek and eye appealing modern design
  • Soft closing seat included
  • Special holes to reach the bolts - includes bolt caps and wax ring

TOTO CST244EF#01 Entrada Two-Piece Elongated 1.28 GPF Universal Height Toilet, Cotton White
  • Clean, modern two-piece elongated bowl and tank set
  • E-Max 1.28 GPF flushing system, creates a powerful flush
  • Toliet seat NOT included. Must purchase separately
  • Universal Height for more comfort across a broader range of individuals
  • ADA, WaterSense, CALGreen, and CEC compliant

Round bowl toilet

Round bowl toilets are smaller than elongated toilets and measure 16.5 inches in length. Round toilets are more attractive than elongated models because they have a circular shape.

The round bowl design makes it ideal for small spaces such as the attic or garage, where you don’t need a powerful toilet.

Pros
  • It can be used in tight spaces.
  • It’s suitable for older or disabled people.
  • It has a traditional look
  • It is more affordable than elongated-bow toilets
Cons
  • It is less powerful.
  • It can be difficult to use and clean.
  • The small area of sitting is not ideal for comfort.

In our opinion, this model American Standard 2988101.020 Cadet 3 FloWise 2-Piece  is better in relation to quality-price, it also has a very good valuation

Sale
American Standard 2988101.020 Cadet 3 FloWise 2-Piece 1.28 GPF Single Flush Right Height Round Front Toilet with Concealed Trapway, White
  • Combination bowl and tank with seat. Residential Use
  • Oversized 3 inches flush valve. Chrome-plated trip lever
  • Siphon action jetted bowl with smooth-sided, concealed trapway
  • EverClean surface inhibits the growth of stain and odor causing bacteria, mold and mildew on the surface
  • Includes top mount slow-close seat and cover with easy lift off feature

Details Comparison Between Elongated and Round Toilet

Appearance

Many of the most popular toilet designs are available in both a rectangular and an elongated front bowl. The bowl’s shape does not affect the style of the toilet. This includes the details on the lid and the skirted bottom.

Only the shape of your bowl will make a difference. A round-fronted toilet bowl is closer than a true circle. The toilet bowl extends into the room less.

An elongated bowl is an oval-shaped bowl that extends several inches into the front of a room. The elongated bowl is more common as bathrooms get larger. This can make it appear more modern. This shape is often associated with smaller, older baths.

It’s easy to use

The round and the elongated toilets can be used in the same way, regardless of whether they are used by a woman or a man. The elongated toilet’s longer and more spacious bowl may make it easier to sit on. This toilet may be more convenient for children and adults, as it is less messy and easier to use.

Space

Manufacturers are responsible for determining the exact dimensions of toilets. An elongated toilet bowl will generally be approximately 2-inches wider in the front than an oval one. Manufacturers also offer a third-size toilet bowl.

To pass all building codes, a toilet must be at least 21 inches in front. Some municipalities and towns may need more space, while ADA-compliant bathrooms require 48 inches. A round-front toilet bowl can save 2 inches on small bathrooms. This could result in a passing or failing building code. Small bathrooms are better served by round bowls.

Installation

Both round and elongated front toilets can be installed in the same manner. If there is a separate bowl and tank, they are connected first. The waste pipe is wrapped in a wax ring and the toilet is lifted at an angle. After twisting the toilet into position, apply pressure to all sides. Finally, the water is connected and bolted into place.

Although elongated bowls are more difficult to lift and move than shorter ones, it doesn’t make a difference in the overall installation.

Prices

A round-front toilet bowl is usually more expensive than an elongated one of the same manufacturer and design. A classic style, two-piece round-front flush toilet of 1.28 gallons will cost around $180. A similar style toilet, but with a longer front, costs approximately $230.

The cost of installing either toilet is between $45 and $130. It will vary depending on the condition and location of the toilet. A round-front toilet will cost between $800 and $1,200 depending on the condition of the pipes and where it is located. $225 and $310 an elongated toilet with the same brand and design costs between $275 and $360.

Both types of toilets use the same amount of water so it doesn’t matter which one you choose.

Maintenance

A round-front toilet may be easier to clean than an elongated one. Some brands have a shorter shape than others. This makes it easier for a cleaner to reach the bottom of the bowl. It is easier to see the interior of the bowl from the front because it is longer. This can make it easier to clean.

The Power of Flush

There are many types of flush technology available, including pressure-assisted and double-cyclone. The toilet’s longer shape may allow for slightly higher pressure if it uses a flush that circulates water through the bowl by force. There is no difference in the performance of other flush technologies. Performance should not differ as long as the toilet is the right size for the bathroom and your home.

Who is the winner? Do you prefer a round or Elongated toilet?

The design of your toilet will depend on many factors, including the space available, how comfortable you require, cleaning ease, cost, and appearance. Many people are now embracing the elongated bowl toilet design. They are more comfortable than traditional round toilets and easier to maintain. Round toilet bowls have been around for a long time and are ideal for small bathrooms. They are also easier to install and cheaper.

If comfort is your goal, we recommend the elongated bowl design. If you have a small bathroom, the round bowl toilet is the best option.

Why would you want an elongated toilet bowl?

An elongated bowl is oval-shaped, and approximately 2 inches longer than a circular toilet. Because they have a larger surface area, elongated toilets are more comfortable than regular toilets.

Is it possible to have an elongated toilet instead of a round one?

Yes. Yes. An elongated toilet will replace a standard round toilet as long as there is enough room for it to fit in and their rough-in measurements are the same. A compact, the elongated toilet can be a great alternative in cases where space is tight.

Can an elongated seat be placed on a round toilet?

No. Elongated and circular toilet bowls have different sizes so their seats cannot be swapped. An elongated toilet seat won’t fit in an elongated or round bowl. The same goes for round toilet seats.

Do you prefer a round or elongated bowl toilet?

You can determine if your toilet is rectangular or elongated by measuring the length of its bowl between the seat mounting holes and the front. It is considered elongated if it measures 18.5 inches. A round bowl will measure approximately 16.5 inches in length.

Do we need to consider water usage and the trap?

Ask about the trap and how much water each toilet uses. There is no difference between the two models. Why? The only thing that makes these types different is the length of their bowls. Both the bottoms are nearly identical in both cases. They hold and flush the exact same amount of water in both cases.

What is the difference between the installation?

These are the steps involved in installing a toilet. The tank and bowl must be connected together first. Then, wrap a wax ring around your waste pipe. Next, the toilet is placed in the desired location while keeping the angle correct. After the toilet is installed, the installer applies pressure to all sides and fixes it in place. Finally, the water supply is connected.
Both models have similar installation processes. Due to their larger sizes, the only problem with elongated bowls is shifting them.

CONCLUSION

While the round toilets are slowly disappearing, elongated toilets continue to be more popular. Most round toilets can be found in older homes or institutions. Compact elongated toilets are a viable replacement for round toilets. Elongated wall-hung toilets are also replacing them. So what factors affect the decision to buy an elongated vs round toilet?

Toilets mainly arrive in two variants — round and elongated — depending on the shape of the bowl. And it often becomes confusing as to which would be the better option for you. Therefore, today, let’s discuss the major differences and lay out the pros and cons of elongated vs round toilet — so that you can make an informed decision. 

Leave a Comment